The Allure of Punishment

Michael Baugh CDBC CPDT-KSA

I’ll start with a bold statement of my opinion. It is normal for us humans to feel compelled to punish our dogs when they do something we don’t like. Normal. Punishment, by definition, makes the behavior stop – even if only for a short while. When our dog’s annoying or upsetting behavior stops – our behavior, by definition, is reinforced. “Effective punishment reinforces the punisher, who is therefore more likely to punish again in the future, even when antecedent arrangements and positive reinforcement would be equally, or more, effective.” (Friedman, 2010).

We punish, or attempt to punish, all the time. And we aim our vitriol all over the place, not just at our dogs. A guy tries to cut us off in traffic and we honk or we flip him off or both. If he stops we are reinforced. We may feel better even if he doesn’t. Our dog barks – we yell – he stops. Our behavior is reinforced. Dog pulls – yank collar – he slows. You see where this is going.

We get hooked on punishment. In some cases we can’t even think about how to influence behavior any other way. And as Dr. Susan Friedman (2010) notes, punishment doesn’t help us teach our dog what we want him to do. Stop barking. Stop pulling. Okay, but now what? What do we want the dog to do?

Houston-dog-Stella-KitchenAdd to that, our actions may only punish the dog’s misbehavior in the moment or in a certain context. The effect is fleeting. The dog may stop pulling for a moment or two and then resume (same with barking or… name your doggie crime). That often leads to chronic yelling, leash yanking, or worse. Our attempts to punish increase in frequency and intensity, true testament that they are not having any lasting effect. Before long it’s simply indiscriminate abuse.

And there are other problems, especially when it comes to how fear and pain in the name of training can affect our dog. Studies dating back decades point to the emotional damage fear and pain have on the dog being punished. The data is clear, not only as it relates to dogs but other species including human children. The use of physical violence as a means of training correlates with anxiety related behavior in dogs (Hiby et al., 2004). Specifically there is a relationship between physical punishment and aggression in dogs (Hsu and Sun, 2010). In many cases using confrontational training techniques can elicit an immediate aggressive response from the dog, putting the human in danger (Herron, Shofer, Riesner, 2009).

But, we still do it. Our punishing behavior is reinforced. No matter that the effects are temporary. They are immediate and we get hooked. Sometimes, nothing beats a quick fix for a human. The cost to the dog takes a back seat to convenience. There are still trainers who sell it, teach it, and never look back. In many places, not to mention TV and the Internet, that’s the norm. Punish. Jerk. Pinch. Hit. Shock. Do what it takes to assert your will and assume dominance. If you care to be more euphemistic, give a correction. It’s all the same to the dog, and the flaws and side effects remain nonetheless.

So what are we, the punishment addicted, to do? Admit to the problem? Make amends? Begin behaving differently? I’m not being cheeky. The answer to all is, “yes.”

The Science of behavior change is unambiguous. It points us clearly and unashamedly in the direction of positive reinforcement training. Like the old and outdated ways, it too yields quick results. But the effects are lasting. Positive reinforcement is also the communication tool we are looking for to teach our dogs what we want them to do. There are no unanswered questions. Instead of barking, come here – lie down – relax. Instead of pulling – walk here – keep an eye on me. And, the side effects? They are nothing short of delightful – joy, enthusiasm, and an eagerness in our dogs for learning.

As the cliché goes, it’s up to us. We can learn. We can get hooked on today’s training methods and leave yesterday’s in the dust. We can take on the burden, a light one at that, of learning some new skills. We can take the burden off our dogs. The allure of positive reinforcement training: seeing our dogs behave better, thrive, and succeed. That, too, can be very reinforcing.

Michael is a dog trainer and behavior consultant. He specializes in fearful and aggressive dog behavior in Houston, TX

This entry was posted in How Dogs Learn, Uncategorized and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

9 Responses to The Allure of Punishment

  1. Carla says:

    Well said!

  2. Tracy Frederico says:

    I have a Toy Fox Terrier that is over 4 years old now and she still potties in the house. I have done the positive reinforcement where she gets treats when she potties outside, every single time. She gets even more praise when she poops outside. Every few days though, she poops in the house. Sometimes it happens right after she has been brought into the house. Even if we have been outside for 15-20 minutes or have just come back from a walk. How do you stop this behavior?

  3. Linda Baragona says:

    I work at a shelter primarily with dogs deemed too traumatized or shy to go to adoptions. I use only positive reinforcement and have very good results. When working with dogs that are dog reactive, positive reinforcement and redirection work consistently to get the dogs to a point where adoption is possible. Part of my job is to educate potential adopters at the shelter and discussion of training always involves the positive reinforcement vs punishment topic. Punishment techniques serve only to further traumatize these animals.

  4. Tricia says:

    Great article and thought provoking…….. Could I also add that we humans have had a long reinforcement history by way of using ‘punishment’ models that still remain strong in our cultures. For instance wars through the ages, prison sentences, traffic rules and fines, law enforcement …… etc At least positive reinforcement is becoming a common language in parenting, school models and sport. We’ll get there!

  5. Steven Slomka says:

    I have 2 Airedales, seemingly untrainable. But if I put the electric collar on, their behavior improves immediately. Without a zap. So, misbehavior isn’t a case of insufficient knowledge. They know what good behavior is, they just need to be motivated to practice it. In their case, if they have the collar on and they start barking, I just show them the remote and they shut up and behave. For now.

  6. I truly agree, I have a very scarred and somewhat of an aggressive dog. She needs behavioral trading which I’m going to look into with the help of her new vet who is fantastic.

  7. Caitlin Coberly says:

    Excellent blog post.

  8. Pingback: The Allure of Punishment – In Dog's Name

Comments are closed.